FFS Forum: Fire Damage Assessment – Tips and Guidance on FFS in the Aftermath of a Process Plant Fire (Part 2 of 2)

By Greg Garic, P.E., Senior Staff Consultant at Stress Engineering Services, Inc. This article appears in the September/October 2021 issue of Inspectioneering Journal.

23 Likes

1 Comment

Topics

API 579-1/ASME FFS-1 - Fitness-For-Service (FFS)

API 579-1/ASME FFS-1, Fitness-For-Service, is a standard developed and published jointly by the American Petroleum Institute (API) and
API RP 585 - Pressure Equipment Integrity Incident Investigation

API RP 585, Pressure Equipment Integrity Incident Investigation, is a recommended practice developed and published by the American Petroleum Institute (API) that provides owner-operators...
Failure Analysis

It is undeniable that every plant will experience equipment failure at some point during its lifetime. Despite this, avoiding failures is the goal of every asset integrity professional in the oil and gas industry. As...
Fitness For Service (FFS)

Fitness for Service (FFS) is a best practice and standard used by the oil & gas and chemical process industries for in-service equipment to determine its fitness for continued service. FFS serves as a rational basis for defining flaw acceptance limits and allows engineers to...
Process Safety Incidents

A Process Safety Incident typically involves an unexpected mechanical integrity failure in a pipeline system or processing facility, often including a fire, explosion, rupture, or hazardous chemical leak. These incidents can be caused by a number factors including
Process Safety Management (PSM)

Process Safety Management (PSM) is a regulation issued by the U.S. Department of Labor's Occupational Safety and Health...

Effect of High Temperature Hydrogen Attack in Dissimilar Materials

May/June 2018 Inspectioneering Journal

HTHA of hydrogen-containing equipment can be prevented with appropriate material selection and fabrication, appropriate welding procedures, regular inspection of equipment using proven, effective technologies and equipment operated by qualified...
Advanced Methods for More Accurate Brittle Fracture Screening Assessments

May/June 2020 Inspectioneering Journal

This article provides an overview of brittle fracture, details on several industry failures, and a summary of deficiencies and concerns with current published methods for screening susceptibility of equipment to potential brittle fracture failures.
Remaining Life Sensitivity to Longitudinal Weld Seam Peaking in High-temperature Low Chrome Piping

July/August 2016 Inspectioneering Journal

This article summarizes a recent finite element analysis (FEA)-based study that employs creep simulation techniques to investigate the elevated temperature response of piping with peaked longitudinal weld seams.
The Hype about Hydrogen Bake-Outs!

May/June 2013 Inspectioneering Journal

With 30 years of refinery experience, I have been through many turnarounds and been involved with a lot of repairs. When I started in the business, we would have inspectors that “owned” their specific pieces of equipment.
High Temperature Life Assessment

May/June 2013 Inspectioneering Journal

Predicting the remaining life of components operating in the creep regime is one of the trickiest problems encountered in the fitness-for-service (FFS) world.

This article is part two of a 2-part series on Fire Damage Assessments.

Part 1| Part 2

Editor’s Note: This is Part 2 of a two-part column on Fire Damage Assessments. It focuses on the important topic of establishing “Heat Exposure Zones” and how to conduct Level 1, 2, and 3 assessments after a fire.

Introduction

In the last edition of the Fitness-for-Service Forum, published in the July/August 2021 issue of Inspectioneering Journal, I began the discussion of Fire Damage Assessments (FDA). In Part 1, I provided a big picture overview of the process of assessing equipment in a post-fire “return- to- service” effort, discussed the involvement of regulators, and highlighted the importance of properly identifying damage mechanisms. In this follow up article, I’m going to talk about the important topic of establishing Heat Exposure Zones and discuss Level 1, 2, and 3 fitness-for-service assessments.

Heat Exposure Zones

Heat exposure zones and the corresponding heat zone maps are enormously important tools in fire damage assessments. They are the key to all the work that follows.

What is a Heat Zone Map?

A heat zone map is a drawing of the plant, with a color-coded overlay indicating the maximum temperature experienced in different areas. Various temperature ranges are associated with Heat Exposure Zones, as defined in API 579, Part 11.

Figure 1 shows an example of a simple heat zone map. Process equipment is included in the drawing with colored areas corresponding to Zones 1 through 6.

Figure 1. Heat zone drawings. — Figure 1. Heat Zone Drawings.

The plan view covers the entire area of the fire, but since temperature can vary with elevation, several elevation views at different cross-sections may also be necessary.

How is a Heat Zone Map Created?

Creating a decent heat zone map takes both experience and skill. It requires very detailed detective work worthy of Sherlock Holmes.

The map team must:

Have knowledge of what types of damage are associated with what temperatures, and
Have the skill and detail orientation to pick out specific evidence of damage.

This content is free for registered users

Create your free account and you'll also get access to:

Unlock one premium article of your choosing per month
Exclusive online content, videos, and downloads
Insightful and actionable webinars

GET STARTED

Interested in unlimited access? VIEW OUR SUBSCRIPTION OPTIONS

Current subscribers and registered users can log in now.

About the Authors

Greg Garic, P.E., Senior Staff Consultant at Stress Engineering Services, Inc.

Greg Garic has over 40 years of experience in pressure systems engineering, particularly in the fitness-for-service assessment of fixed equipment in chemical plants and refineries. He is highly experienced in stress analysis, fracture mechanics, finite element analysis, creep, and high-temperature material behavior. Mr. Garic's practice routinely involves evaluating and... Read more »